Guides · Buyer's guide
A buyer's guide to evidence-based evaluation
3 min read
The questions to ask any performance evaluation tool, what a good answer sounds like, and how Nextdot answers each one.
Most tools in this space look alike in a demo: a review form, a dashboard, some AI. The differences show up in a few questions about where the evidence comes from and who decides. Ask them of every tool on your list, including ours.
1. Where does the evidence come from?
If the answer is "what reviewers type into a form", the review is built on recall. Look for evidence read from the work itself. Nextdot imports work from the tools teams already use, with twelve months backfilled on the first import.
2. Can we run this year's cycle on it?
A tool that only starts collecting evidence on the day you sign up gives you a useful cycle next year. Ask whether past work can be brought in. In Nextdot, the first import takes from 10 minutes to 6 hours, depending on the size of the organization.
3. Who writes the first draft, and who decides?
AI can draft; a person should decide. Check whether a leader can sign an AI draft unchanged. In Nextdot, the leader reads the draft and writes their own evaluation, and nothing is final until they sign it.
4. Can the rating be traced to the work?
Ask to see the evidence behind one rating. In Nextdot, every dimension shows how much evidence stands behind it, down to the record, and the person sees the same evidence their leader sees.
5. Does it use our framework?
Your criteria should drive the evaluation, not the vendor's. Nextdot's framework builder takes your dimensions and weights, key skills shared across job roles, and technical skills per job role.
6. What does the person get out of it?
If the only output is a rating once a year, people will treat the tool as paperwork. Look for development all year: feedback on the work while it happens, a view of how colleagues see their skills, and private help to act on it.
7. What happens to our data?
Ask for facts, not adjectives. Nextdot's are:
- Infrastructure is in the EU.
- Nextdot is ISO 27001 certified and built to meet GDPR requirements.
- No model is trained on customer data.
- Raw imported content is deleted after processing; Nextdot keeps the extracted record, not the source.
- Imported work is anonymous until claimed, and identities of people not yet invited are hidden from admins.
- Assistant conversations are private.
8. What does it cost, all in?
Check what is an add-on. Nextdot has one plan with every feature included, priced per user, and a free trial on your own tools.