Blog · Evidence-based evaluation
An evaluation should read the year, not recall it
2 min read
Most performance reviews are written from memory, at a deadline, about twelve months nobody kept a record of. The fix is not a better form. It is a record.
What memory does to a review
When a cycle opens, a leader sits down with a blank text box per dimension and tries to reconstruct a year. What comes back is what they remember: the last few months, the moments that were loud, the work they happened to see. The quiet project that shipped in March is gone. So is most of the feedback that colleagues gave along the way, because it was never written anywhere the review could find it.
The person being evaluated is in the same position, writing a self-review from what they can still recall. Two partial memories meet in a meeting, and a rating comes out that neither side can trace back to the work.
Faster forms don't fix it
A lot of tooling makes the form faster: reminders, templates, AI that summarizes what reviewers typed. All of it still starts from what people remember to write. If the input is recall, a faster form produces recall sooner.
What a record changes
The work of a year already exists, in the tools teams use every day: tickets, pull requests, documents, chats, meeting transcripts. Read from there, the evidence covers the whole year, not the months people still recall. Each piece of work becomes a dotDot: Work worth talking about — time-bound, owned by whoever's doing it, open for conversation while it happens., the person it belongs to decides whether to keep it, and feedback lands on it while the work happens.
At evaluation time, the draft can then be built per dimension of the organization's own framework, with the evidence behind each dimension shown. The leader reads the draft and writes their own evaluation; nothing is final until they sign it. And the person sees the same evidence their leader sees.
Three questions to ask of any review process
- Where does the evidence come from: what people remember, or what they did?
- Can the person see what their rating was based on?
- Does the year still count if nobody wrote it down at the time?